Council members Zapf, Bry present their short-term vacation rental proposal
Published - 09/25/17 - 02:40 PM | 5684 views | 0 0 comments | 36 36 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A new “coastal” proposal to curb short-term vacation rental proliferation, in lieu of a less-restrictive counterproposal by inland City Council members, was vetted at a Sept. 20 Pacific Beach Town Council meeting.

District 2 Councilmember Lorie Zapf told residents she was joining with District 1 Councilmember Barbara Bry of La Jolla, to present a compromise STVR plan. Zapf said that plan would help eliminate mini hotels in single-family neighborhoods. She also said their proposal will preserve property owner's rights to supplement their income with short-term rentals, as long as they reside at the address and are not absentee owners.

The Bry-Zapf plan follows another proposal for regulating short-term rentals by Council members David Alvarez, Mark Kersey, Scott Sherman and Chris Ward. That proposal would require three-night minimum stays, as well as set up a permitting and enforcement system for STVRs, in addition to providing renters with a code of conduct covering noise, trash and parking issues.

The City Council is scheduled to consider the two competing short-term rental proposals on Monday, Oct. 23.

Hillary Nemchik, Bry's communications director, presented the broad outlines of the Bry-Zapf plan.

“Bry's proposed regulations for short-term rentals preserves our housing stock and laws while allowing property owners to supplement their income,” said Nemchik. “It's a workable compromise. Bry wants to enforce current laws prohibiting STVRs in residential zones.”

Nemchik said the Bry-Zapf proposal would require STVRs to be less than 30 days. She added it would preserve property owner's ability to homeshare, renting out a room in their home. She added new proposed home-sharing regulations would prevent outside interests from coming in to residential neighborhoods, buying property there, then turning it into what essential becomes a “mini hotel.”

City Attorney Mara Elliott, who has taken the stand that short-term rentals are illegal in residential areas under the city's existing municipal code, also spoke about her stance.

Characterizing STVRs and a “hot-button issue,” Elliott said, “There are no laws on the books in the city allowing short-term rentals in residential zones. If it's not addressed in the (building) codes — it's not legal. That is the position I came out with.”

Of the two most-recent STVR proposals being forwarded, Elliott commented, “I feel like we're getting somewhere.”

Zapf was strident in her commitment to resolving the STVR issue once and for all.

“You and I have property rights in a single-family zone,” Zapf said. “The goal of the city is to protect the integrity of the neighborhoods. It's our obligation to protect neighborhood quality, character and livability.”

Arguing out-of-town investors are “coming in and buying up whole homes and renting them out,” that Zapf noted results in “opening up a hotel right in the middle of our neighborhoods. They're disrupting our lives.”

In November 2016, the City Council voted 7-2 to reject a proposal by then-council President Sherri Lightner that would have prohibited short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods zoned for single-family homes. Zapf was Lightner's only colleague to support her plan.
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments are back! Simply post the comment (it'll complain about you failing the human test) then simply click on the captcha and then click "Post Comment" again. Comments are also welcome on our Facebook page.